What do chickens that cross the road and stinky armpits have in common? They’re both illegal, of course! Not, everywhere, but in Quitman and San Luis Obispo Counties, respectively. (source) And it’s not just armpits – offensive body odor of any kind is outlawed in San Luis Obispo County libraries. Yes, libraries.
Some things though are perfectly legal, though, like putting questionable chemicals in personal care products without always disclosing them. (source) In a previous post I shared five ingredients to look out for in deodorant – including one that has already been banned in one state – along with alternatives like this man-stink killer deodorant recipe, sensitive skin recipe and my fave pre-made deodorant.
However, several of you have asked about how to make deodorant that doesn’t need to be applied with your fingertips, so I thought I’d share one of my favorite recipes! Instead of baking soda, this solid deodorant recipe relies on kaolin clay and magnesium to keep you smelling fresh. If you have sensitive skin – or even if you don’t – I hope you love it as much as I do!
About The Ingredients
Shea Butter
Rich in skin soothing vitamin E, raw shea butter is a non-oily moisturizer that absorbs quickly when applied – super important if you are getting dressed in a hurry!
Cocoa Butter
Known formally as Theobroma cacao (Food of the Gods), cocoa butter is rich in Vitamin E and minerals such as manganese, calcium, iron and zinc. It improves the “glide” of your solid deodorant while nourishing skin.
Kaolin Clay, Bentonite Clay or Diatomaceous Earth
Each of these compounds help neutralize odor. They’re much more gentle than baking soda, which some people find irritating.
Magnesium
In addition to blocking odor, magnesium is an essential co-factor for over 300 enzyme driven reactions in the human body. When applied alone it can sting a little, which is why I prefer to incorporate it in this formula.
Beeswax
Provides a barrier of protection while still allowing skin to breathe. Also, it’s what keeps the deodorant bar solid.
Essential Oils (Optional)
A couple of my favorite blends are:
- 20 drops tea tree essential oil and 16 drops orange essential oil
- 20 drops tea tree essential oil and 16 drops lavender essential oil
However if your skin is very sensitive, you might want to skip essential oils or stick to ones that are considered very soothing, like lavender.
A Note On Transitioning To Natural Deodorant
If you’re transitioning to natural deodorant for the first time, you may find that it doesn’t work for you right away. As I wrote in this article,
“Though our primary detox pathways are through the liver, kidneys, colon and lymph system, our skin and lungs also assist with detoxification. It makes sense that if we’ve been applying a deodorant containing parabens, aluminum, propylene glycol, and/or triclosan, our body may begin working to eliminate it once we switch. If you think this might be your issue, here’s a helpful article on how to detox your armpits.”
Homemade Solid Deodorant For Sensitive Skin (Without Baking Soda)
Ingredients
- 2 tablespoons grated, packed beeswax (.5 ounces by weight) – where to buy beeswax
- 2 level tablespoons shea butter (1 ounces by weight) – where to buy shea butter
- 2 rounded tablespoons grated cocoa butter (.4 ounces by weight) – where to buy cocoa butter
- 1 tablespoon + 1 teaspoon magnesium chloride powder (I ground magnesium flakes in my coffee grinder)
- 1 tablespoon kaolin clay (food grade diatomaceous earth or bentonite clay will also work) – where to buy kaolin clay
- 24 – 36 drops essential oil (optional)
Equipment
- Deodorant tube, either recycled or new – where to find deodorant tubes online
- Double boiler (or a stainless steel bowl set in side a pot of boiling water)
- Coffee grinder (optional)
To Make
1. Melt all ingredients (except essential oils) in a double boiler over low heat.
2. Allow the mixture to cool for one to two minutes – it will separate if it is added to the deodorant tube while still very hot. While it is still liquid, add essential oils and pour into deodorant tube. Store out of direct sunlight.
To Use
Apply a thin layer – not much is needed!
Clean-Up Tip
After you’ve poured your deodorant in your container, place your pot back in the double boiler so that the thin layer of remaining deodorant heats up. When it’s hot, wipe it out with old newspaper or paper towels.
FREE Ebook: DIY Body Care Gifts Made Simple
Do you want to give gorgeous, handcrafted gifts for family and friends, without spending a bunch of time on them?
Then I’d love to give you a free copy of DIY Body Care Gifts Made Simple – my step-by-step guide to making gorgeous handcrafted gifts without stressing yourself out – as a gift for signing up for my newsletter. I’ll show you how to make vintage labels, luxurious lotion bars, lip balms, sugar scrubs, body sprays and more like a pro. Sign up for my newsletter and you’ll be redirected to the download page immediately!
Carolina
Hello! Thanks for your recipe. Can I use magnesium sulphate (epsom salt) instead of magnesium chloride? Can I skip the magnesium of the ingredients?
Thanks
Heather
I haven’t tested it with sulphate so I can’t say for sure. If you try it please let us know how it works!
Sarah Carr
I followed your recipe but used Epsom Salts instead of the magnesium chloride and it worked great. Thankyou for your wonderful ideas.
faith
hey Sarah, did the Epsom Salts melted completely in the recipe?
Holly
I used epsom salts and i’m seeing little white lumps in the melt…whisking doesn’t seem to be making it dissolve…anyone?
can i put it in the blender?
Debbie
you should not sub magnesium sulphate for magnesium chloride, you will not get the same benefits…also magnesium chloride is water soluble, and is not oil soluble. I will try this recipe again with magnesium oil to see if I can get it to work out(may need a surfactant) otherwise making a magnesium cream deodorant is in my future.
Patricia
Just a note, I seem to remember that magnesium “oil” is not an oil at all. It is magnesium flakes dissolved in water. Am I remembering correctly?
nichole
How long does it last fter you make it?
Laura
I just made a batch of this, and it seems like the magnesium didn’t dissolve, making the deodorant gritty… did you have this happen? What can I do to fix that?
Thanks!
mer
I also had the magnesium remain at the bottom of my pan…didn’t incorporate at all.
Jo-Ann
I used Magnesium Citrate Pure Powder in a similar deodorant. Didn’t have any problems with it incorporating. Hope this helps.
Nicole
I had the same problem I wish she would respond to you
Natalie Pattinson
i used epsom salt and crushed it with a mortar and pestle. worked good for me.
Debra Rawls
I would say maybe not heated enough to dissolve good.
Kirsten
I agree re: the heat because I used epsom salts and it dissolved. I found that removing from the double boiler, while stirring, let sit on the counter about 2 minutes while stirring, then put back into double boiler helped with dissolving.
Sam
Nope, I had the same issue with powdered magnesium chloride not melting even on high heat and remaining like sludge at the bottom. Argh…. Any ideas on how to resolve this will be a huge help.
jessica buchanan
How many sticks does this recipe make? If I want to make 8, do I need to adjust the ingredients accordingly ?
Maegan
Next Time I make this I will use magnesium oil instead of powder and maybe up the clay so it won’t come out watery.
jent
do you still sweat ?
Sue
Hi, I make healthy snacks and treats and have been getting ready to add healthy soaps and body products……So on your deodorant recipe, just wondering how I could substitue and leave out the shea butter. It kinda scares me as it goes grainy if it isn’t just right, even later on.
Would it work to use coconut oil in its place, and maybe add more cocoa butter?
I have diatomaceous earth, also arrowroot if needed….I am still getting mag chloride.
What do you know about stearic acid in deodorant? I know it helps things set up, and if its extracted right…..its what is in cocoa butter, shea butter that helps them be more solid….so would it work to put in about 5-6% by weight to make a more solid deodorant bar if you didn’t use shea butter? Is it good? Ok? Bad?
Sorry for all the unorganized questions….just reaching, hoping someone can help me here.
Helen
Have you tried to use Mango butter ?
Roxanne
How many tubes does this recipe make?
Maria
Hello! I just discovered your wonderful site. I don’t know exactly where to ask, but in this recipe can I possibly add activated charcoal or substitute it for the clays? How would I incorporate the charcoal and how much should I try to add? Thank you in advance.
Tara Brady
Hi there! I DEF would not suggest charcoal since it will stain your clothes and armpit! You could use diatamaceous earth (D.E.) baking soda, arrowroot (can’t remember if this is IN the recipe or not sorry lol), possibly instead of the clays. Baking soda alone usually doesn’t do much for odor & same with arrowroot. It’s when you start combining all these great ingredients plus then the boost of the clays &/or D.E. that you really notice a difference. If you don’t have D.E. or bentonite clay I highly suggest grabbing some on Amazon. They’re sold by the POUND (also more or less, whatever you want) but a pound can be as low as $10. They are worth their weight in gold for internal use, external, beauty, household care… the list goes on and on and it is worth investing in!
Michelle
Hi 🙂 Actually, i made a similar recipe on the weekend as a “summer” deodorant.. it worked awesome. in the winter, I use a formula with shea, coconut, sunflower oil, glycerin, baking soda, koalin clay, a bunch of essential oils, arrowroot powder, etc… I don’t find this effective in the summer at all.
I made a recipe using all these ingredients in addition to a small quantity of activated charcoal and magnesium oil and beeswax. holy moly…. i don’t think i can go back to my ‘other’ formula. I’m dry. all day in 30C heat. DRY. and I don’t smell. i only applied once and a very thin layer. the trick is to use a very VERY small amount of charcoal so your deodorant is light grey. so.. half a tsp to start.
Taaliba
Michelle, that awesome. Would mind posting your recipe. Thanks!
Marcy
Michelle, I would love your recipe. Would you please post?
Cindy
Hi Michelle! Definitely sounds like something that I need to try. I’ve just about given up on finding a natural deodorant that actually works. I’m a big fan of charcoal. Would love your recipe too. If you have already posted it, please direct me to it. 🙂
Meryll
Could you give us some quantities for ingredients please !
Marie
Hi michelle, would love the recipe, mine is sub par 🙁
I want to offer a no baking soda option for my clients.
Lori Goodwin
Hi Heather,
I love your natural products! I just wanted to let you know that if you use a metal bowl for your double boiler, it will deactivate the negative charge in the bentonite clay. Then you will lose the detox benefits of the clay. Not sure if that’s what you were going for, but you might as well take advantage of it. Just FYI Keep up the great work!
Rhana
I’ve tried making a natural deodorant with Epsom salt but even when I blend it first to make it less course, the bottom of the deodorant is very grainy and stings when applying.
Fiona
I use a magnesium spray every day after my shower ( from WM’s blog). I don’t wash it off. If I put magnesium in this deodorant, am I overdoing it? Could it be too much mg?
Rachel Delvalle
Has anybody tried magnesium oxide? I have a ton of it from some other project and would like to substitute for the magnesium chloride.
CINDY CHANEY SANTOS
I tried this recipe and had to take out the cocoa butter. I was teaching a fitness class, seeing and was horrified to see milky white sweat. Taking it out stopped that. Also a fantastic EO combo that is gentle for my sensitive underarm skin is Ginger and Geranium.
Leslie
I’ve lived in San Luis Obispo, ca my whole life and never knew about this ordinance! But it doesn’t surprise me. There are very stuffy uptight people in this co. . . Lol! This recipe looks awesome. These ingredients look like I could reuse my bowls or double boiler for cooking after, right? I know with soap it’s only for soap. . . .
Heather
Yes, you can totally reuse your equipment. And actually, in many cases you can with soap making tools, too. More info in my post on soap making myths.
Natalie
That is crazy about San Luis Obispo! Love the random facts. It is so funny – I just thought of grinding the mag flakes up in my coffee grinder last night to add to my deodorant! Glad to know it works!
Heather
It totally does, and isn’t that crazy? 🙂
Linda
What about using liquid magnesium? How much should I use?
Lulu
About a tablespoon:).
Cate
Yay! This looks great and easy! Thanks so much for sharing!
maeghan
Hey there! I love your blog and it has helped me through being a first time mama(: I had a few questions for you!
My boy is 17 months and im worried about the fact that he still prefers to be mostly breastfed. We are doing the babyled weaning process, I always offer him foods but he mostly plays with it. Though he does eat any kind of meat, and he will drink smoothies with greens, fruits, healthy fats, cod liver oil, probiotics..
Im just worried if its okay for him to be still breastfeeding at this age as his main nutrition…? Also I might add he is growing, healthy and happy (:
Another topic, ever since I got pregnant I have had swollen, red gums…I use Redmond clay toothpaste and even use activated charcoal…do you think since im still breastfeeding and maybe my hormones are out of whack thats causing it?
Thank you!!!!! I hope to hear from you!
Maeghan
Heather
Hi Maeghan, when my first child was around 14-15 months old she was still getting most of her nutrients from breast milk. She ate some, but mostly played with her food. Anyway, I remember being a little concerned about this and deciding to read up. After researching and talking with other moms, I felt comfortable with letting her take the lead and just continued to offer solids at meal time. I don’t remember when it was but she did continue to eat more over time and it all worked out fine. She was definitely well-nourished and is a very adventurous eater now. Though I can’t say what you should do, I hope maybe sharing my experience will help in some small way. If you suspect that there might be an underlying issue I would definitely take her in to get checked out, but I personally think that it can be perfectly normal.
Regarding the swollen gums, I would see a holistic dentist. Pregnancy can cause changes in the immune system that can cause a (usually mild) form of gum disease. If you haven’t researched the benefits of oil pulling for plaque-induced gingivitis you might start here: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4382606/
It’s thought to be very effective 🙂
Erica
Dry brushing your gums lightly in a circular motion is a great way to fight off gum disease. Also I have a crown that was not put in right and the guns were irritated and inflamed…I put a little tea tree oil on there and it worked out great. Good luck!
Diana
Hi Maeghan!
I totally relate! My son is 18mo and I felt the same! Some days he eats very well but other days he resorts to the breast all day long! My husband jokes that he is going to drain me! Thank you for bringing this up, and thank you Heather for sharing your experience with all of us!
Taaliba
I breastfed mine for 2 years. I started the weaning process 3 months in advance. This allow me to take my time and allowed the baby to adjust to the change. I also shorten the length of the breast feeding session and eliminated on demand breast feeding. I breast fed once in the morning. Replaced the afternoon breast feeding with solid foods, healthy snacks and liquids. Later on in the day I would breastfeed before the baby would take a nap. Then offer solid foods and liquids for dinner. Be sure to give lots of hugs and kisses. It’s o.k. to say no to the baby.
CrazyMama
I could’ve sworn this started with “My boy is 17 yo…” which makes for a much more humorous post!
Lisette
Hi H!
I write you so much I feel like we are pals! So is this recipe more effective than your other sensitive skin deodorant that uses arrowroot powder, or are you just offering another sensitive skin deo option? I have all the ingredients so I am interested in making this asap! I made a homemade one with little baking soda but after three weeks, my pits have once again reacted and I have a rash! Bummer. I am interested in trying this!
Heather
Haha, me too! I think I will go back and test the other sensitive skin recipes with the addition of magnesium when I run out of my current stick, but for now I’m loving this stick because of the additional magnesium. The shea butter is also amazing for sensitive skin 🙂
Aislinn
I don’t have magnesium flakes at this time. Can I make this recipe without it? I really want to make deodorant today, and I want a solid version. I’ll order magnesium flakes going forward, but I’m looking for a “right now” recipe because I actually have time blocked out specifically for making deodorant today and that won’t happen again for me for several weeks. Thanks!
jamie mannette
Did you manage ok with out the magnesium?
Gail @ Rese Activewear
This is excellent. Thanks so much for posting this. I love the idea of a natural deodorant and this recipe may have finally pushed me to take the plunge.
Anna
Wow this is so cool. I never knew I could refill my bought natural deodorant container. Super!
Joanna Vanderkooi
I am so lazy right now. Does anyone MAKE this to sell? I would buy it!
Katie
scratchmommy.com
Pasha
I have tried every recipe and after a while I start to smell a little funky. Most recently I tried ozone layer deodorant, a very interesting concept. Thoughts?
Renate
Have you tried straight unflavored Milk of Magnesia? It works like a charm for me, but like Mommypotamus said, you have to apply it with your fingertips. A bottle lasts for like 6 months, tho, and I can add water when it starts to get super thick and stick to the sides and keep on using it for even longer.
Leslie
I made this last night, thank you very much for this easy, effective recipe. I didn’t have cocoa butter, so I used more shea. I added tea tree and lavender. It works pretty good at keeping you smelling fresh. I can’t use baking soda, I get a rash. Happy there’s this alternative. Thank you.
Anna
This is a really nice sounding recipe. I was always a bit sceptical about baking soda in DIY deodorants so this seems to be a great alternative. I am looking forward to making it!
Anna
Breinne Chavers
Hi!
I love your blog and I’m totally obsessed with it! I’m making this deodorant for myself and for my sister in law who has very sensitive skin and I was wondering if it expires?
Thank you! 🙂
Laura
Hi!
I don’t have cocoa butter. Would it work to double then shea butter?
Thanks for the recipe!
Danielle
Interested in this question! Let me know what you find out!:)
Ali
I made this today with the bentonite clay, since that’s what I had on hand. I LOVE the end result, but have a few questions…To avoid exposure to hormone disrupters that leach out of heated plastic, I chose a small mason jar as my container. I’d prefer a roll-on container; does anyone has suggestions for one that is non-plastic? Also, since bentonite clay can’t be stirred with anything metal, and the mixture required constant stirring during cooling to avoid separation, I resorted to a plastic knife for stirring… again, hormone disrupters probably leaching into my product 🙁 Does anyone know if wooden popsicle sticks are made without chemicals? Or does anyone else have suggestions for another non-toxic, non-metal small stirring utensil that would work for small batches like this one? Thanks in advance, and thanks Heather for sharing this great recipe!!
Gina
Silicone spatulas would work for the utensil to stir the clay.
J Wittmuss
Bamboo! Find somewhere that sells bamboo spoons. Pretty cheap and safe! I have a small Pampered Chef spoon I use just for such things!
Caroline
I actually use the chopsticks that come free with our Chinese food delivery orders. They work great for stirring just about everything!
Sarah
I have a home business making soaps, lotions, and various natural body products, and I use those cheap bamboo skewers you can buy in a big bag for next to nothing to stir all my lotions! They work great and won’t leach anything into your final product. Great suggestion!
Laura
I was wondering how to substitute magnesium oil for the magnesium flakes (magnesium chloride powder) in this recipe. Would I need to decrease the liquid a little? Also, is the amount of Bentonite clay or diatomaceous earth completely interchangeable in this recipe?
Thank you very much. I enjoy reading your information!
Lee
Others may have a different experience, but I would say it is best to use the powdered flakes. Magnesium oil is not oil. It is the flakes dissolved, at a high concentration, in water. And oil and water do not mix. When trying to use the MO, you will find that your finished product is hit or miss. Most often after a time, you will find the MO weeping from your product. Also, there are no preservative ingredient in this product (it’s not needed) any introduction of liquid leads to potential issue. I sell my products so I have to be careful with preparation. Any introduction of liquid to an anyhydrous product opens the door for mold.
Sorry to be so verbose, but one thing to consider with Bentonite clay is color. Bentonite is gray in color, that has the potential to stain clothes. You may want to consider a white kaolin clay. It works well. They are interchangeable and you can even mix and match if you feel like it. This is a great recipe. Try it as is and then experiment. I use arrowroot powder, with kaolin clay AND DE. I think they each add something, but it is not necessary. Hope that helps.
Mary
I have been trying unsuccessfully to make a solid deodorant using MO in addition to the EO’s, melted Beeswax and using Arrowroot Flour… I keep finding that when the ready made MO gets heated it turns into a rubbery eraser like consistency and when I try to apply as a solid, it breaks off in little chunks. Have I converted it back to its crystal solid state by heating?
Nicole
Lee, would you mind sharing the ratios you’re using for the DE, arrowroot powder and kaolin? It sounds like you have it down! Thank you!
Cara
I have the clay paste instead of powder, can I use that? Would the portions be different? Also, can I use a little coconut oil instead of cocoa butter and just increase the Shea butter to keep it firm?
Heather
Do you have any idea why my Magnesium Chloride will not melt? I ground it to a powder as fine as I could get it, and there are still tiny little lumps in the finished product. I don’t know yet if it is going to work the same or not yet, as it is still cooling.
Linda
I would like this to be answered as well. I saw it posted twice and it has never received a response.
Natalya
Magnesium Chloride is not soluble in oils, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnesium_chloride
Heather
It doesn’t melt in the oils, but when powdered finely should be distributed evenly throughout. 🙂
Beth
Could I use Epsom salts instead of magnesium chloride? I know there is a slight chemical difference, but would they serve the same purpose?
Also a question not related to the deodorant–I want to try making the coconut oil soap, but don’t want such a large batch. Can I divide each ingredient in half and get the same outcome? Has anyone tried this?
Thank you for this informational blog; it is so helpful!
Stevee
Epsom salts aren’t absorbed into the skin like Mag Chloride. It’s much more beneficial to use the latter.
MEAGAN
Can the DE be too abrasive for sensitive underarm skin? I understand that on a microscopic level, it is very sharp. Could that potentially damage the epidermal layer?
Virginie
Hello,
I love your blog. In case you would post about natural deodorants that are in the market right now, please consider this before. I tried Green Beaver Wild Rose Deodorant. After the first use of this deodorant, my armpits burned and itched due to the Propanediol in this product, which is a chemical compound that causes skin irritation. It has acute effect when in contact with skin. See scientific data here:http://www.sciencelab.com/msds.php?msdsId=9924723
page 1, section 3.
Also, I smelled like sweat all day since the product does not really neutralize the odors. it was a cold day but still I smelled of sweat. So overall, I disliked this product and would not recommend it.
Tanya S
For this recipe…
1. Can I use she’s butter instead of cocoa butter?…I don’t have any cocoa butter.
2. Magnesium flakes grinding…seriously…just in coffee grinder…no special cleaning after?
Thanks! I’ve tried about 4 diff deo recipes from diff sites…In desperate. Also…breast cancer runs in my family bad…I will not go back to reg deo.
Ryan
Hi Heather,
I just made this and ended up with sludge at the bottom of my double boiler that appears to be undissolved magnesium. I kept heating past the point of the other ingredients melting for a good 15 – 20 minutes. My final product only filled up half of my deodorant tube, so I think almost none of the magnesium dissolved. Any ideas what I did wrong? I purchased the flakes through your link and ground them in a mortar & pestle. I did not grind to a super fine powder, so I’m wondering if it needs to be finely ground in order to dissolve. I also measured by weight when you provided that info.
Thanks
Heather
Hi Ryan, magnesium is water soluble but unfortunately does not dissolve in oil. In this recipe it needs to be finely ground so that it is suspended throughout the mixture.
Denitra
Hi Heather!
I ground my magnesium in a coffee grinder so it is very fine but still crystalizes and gathers atthe bottom of the solution. The result is like hard crystals rubbing underarm which hurts. Any suggestion? Could it be shea butter thats not creamy or just the magnesium? The first time the deo was warmer and the second time I let it cool almost too long but got the same result.
Leo
Hi Heather,
Can the flakes be replaced with Magnesium Oil?
Thanks
Lily
Hi, have you tried powdered MG Hydroxide or Orotate instead? Or would it be a waste to buy?
Joni
Hi! I love this recipe, it works well, smells awesome, and works in the deodorant tube. How do you keep the magnesium from clumping? I constantly mix it and it seems seems to lum at the bottom.
Lee
I love having magnesium in my deo. I sell it in many of my products. The key with the magnesium for me is to make sure it is ground fine and to allow the deo mixture to cool slightly. Essentially, you are going for suspension. If the mixture is too liquid, the powder will sink to the bottom. If it is cooled and beginning to thicken a bit, the powder will suspend through the mixture. It also helps to premix it with a some oil first and then add it. Give it a try. I hope you will find it worth it.
Mary
does this keep you dry? as well as controlling odor?
Aliona
Hi Mary,
Unfortunately this recipe does not work for me … the odor is coming back 2-3 hours after using it … 🙁 And I normally do not sweat a lot.
Aliona
Katii
I just wanted to point out that using a metal bowl to mix if using bentonite clay will render the clay ineffective! Use anything non metal when mixing bentonite 🙂
Aliona
Hi Heather,
I followed the recipe word to word and the deodorant came out really nice and smooth. The problem is it does not work well for me – already after 2-3 hours I start smelling again … Any idea how to make it more effective? Adding baking soda is out of question as I am sensitive to it (learned the hard way).
Thanks a lot! Aliona
Jackie G
I realize this comment is several months late, but maybe someone will find it helpful. I’ve found if I spray apple cider vinegar on my pits before showering, I don’t sweat or smell nearly as much throughout the day, and with the natural deo there is no smell at all. Hope that helps!
Marly Harris
I’ve been using milk of magnesia as a deodorant for four years. I work out daily and I’m never smelly. Now, it’s definitely not an anti-perspirant but I wouldn’t want that anyway. I apply it with a cotton pad (Delon). It also does not leave any white stain on clothing. And it’s certainly inexpensive.
My baby boy will be 56 in July. One of the best experiences of my life was 9-1/2 months of breast feeding Mark. No food, just mommy and liquid vitamins. It certainly worked well. He’s healthy and gorgeous.
Chaz
Would this work as a cream? I prefer cream style but am not sure whether this recipe is only for the solid texture.
Denise
it should! just leave out the beeswax!
Cheryl
I’m not sure that the magnesium will absorb unless it’s dissolved. I tried doing some searching online, and all applications I found required that it be dissolved in water. I have been making deodorant with magnesium oil and haven’t had any problems yet. However, I may end up just removing it from my deodorant and spraying it on my arm pits before applying my deodorant.
Kelsey
Hi there,
I have your book and am very grateful, so wonderful to have go -to recipes! Oddly, I doubled this recipe twice (actually the stick deodorant with baking soda) and only came out with 3 tubes of deodorant. I bought the deodorant tubes on Amazon– https://www.amazon.com/DMtse-Deodorant-Containers-Empty-Pack/dp/B00CMF4CIM?ie=UTF8&psc=1&redirect=true&ref_=oh_aui_detailpage_o06_s00 <– maybe they are much larger than the ones you use?
Secondly, and most importantly, I can't get the deodorant to come up when I twist the bottom. I've tried putting them in the fridge, then it's way too hard, then letting them sit out, even outside for a bit, but it's too soft. Any tips or tricks?
THank you!
Marisa
I have the same problem: I tried the stick recipe with baking soda, but it’s too soft to apply in stick form. I hope we can figure out how to make this work!
Laura
Thanks for the recipe which I will start with and develop into my own recipe with a few things different:)
Some of the things people asked in the comments had to do with odor coming back and using magnesium oil.
1. Odor coming back. Sometimes we need to do more than try to cover up odor. I have been working on my pit smell for a while and found it is a process rather than a quick fix. First start with a good diet and lots of water. Next be sure to move your lymph. There are many lymph glands under the arms. Try this experiment. At the end of a day that you didn’t sweat a lot smell both underarms or your shirt. Are you right handed? Does your left pit smell more? Usually we move more and do more on our dominant side. Lymph is stagnating a bit on the other side. This seems to be correlated to more odor. Try moving your non dominant arm more and moving lymph evenly.
Also if you are magnesium deficient you may have more odor so taking magnesium internally and applying magnesium oil topically can help lower the odor factor. In fact for years I’ve sprayed my armpits with a light spray of magnesium oil and that works well as deodorant. Just wipe any excess off as it can stain clothing. (I only had that problem once and since then I spray lightly and blot excess) If you have magnesium oil you can add a few drops of essential oil and use that until you get the magnesium flakes to make this recipe.
Also I bought a really good deodorant paste that uses Magnesium Hydroxide in powder form that works great. I don’t have magnesium hydroxide but I do have ancient minerals magnesium chloride as call for in this recipe. I can’t wait to try this recipe to see if it works and feels better than my deodorant paste. Body odor probably is more easily controlled by keeping your body clean and detoxed inside and out.
Lucy
Hey Heather, I really love this post! I’ve always wanted to make my own deodorant but never got around to it, so I’ll try your recipe. Gotta love cocoa butter! 😉
Thanks
Michelle
Hi there! I made this recipe yesterday, and tried it out. It doesn’t last me all day, but I tried it again this morning at about 9:00 am, and it’s now 3:30pm, and no odor, so far so good!! I’ll keep you posted. Thanks so much for the recipe!?
Larissa
Is it possible to use soy wax in deodorant instead of beeswax?
Nidhi Sachdeva
Hi Heather,
Thanks for your wonderful recipes and posts. Really love it all.
Couple of questions regarding this recipe:
1. Does the powdered magnesium incorporate well in the recipe? I felt last time it didn’t mix well in oils last time I tried, perhaps I made a mistake…would you recommend that it’s used as magnesium oil. I usually make my own with distilled water and MgCl.
2. Do you recommend diatomaceous earth over kaolin clay? Just worried about any yellowing of the clothes and want to avoid it.
Thanks very much in advance for your reply. Waiting…
Marci
Mommypotamus,
I made the solid deodorant last night with the magnesium chloride flakes, which I blended in my bullet. It was about the consistency of course salt. I thought the Mg would melt when melting the other oils and butters, but it didn’t seem to. When I poured it into my stick container there were Mg crystals left at the bottom. I fear not enough Mg made it into my deodorant. Should I have pulverized in the bullet longer?
Ros
Hi Heather.
What a fantastic recipe! Thank you so much for posting
I am going to make it and am hunting for ingredients in the UK right now.
Do you know what the shelf life is please?
Lark Terry
Hi, I just made this and was wondering if it’s normal for it to get clumpy when filling the containers? I stirred for a while and let it cool for a little bit before filling them, but it’s like the magnesium didn’t dissolve (I blended it into a powder like you said). I did six time this batch though.
Amber
Hello! I keep reading that the magnesium needs to be dissolved in water = magnesium oil.
Does the powder make it gritty and/or rough?
Thanks a bunch
Amber
Is it safe to grind them in a coffee grinder? What kind of coffee grinder do you have?
I keep reading it is flammable and everything.
Alejandro
Hey,
I am having a hard time with your recipe. I have tried it twice, but haven’t been able to get everything to blend right. When I put all the ingredients in the double boiler, I melt them all. After, I wait 2 minutes to transfer, however, every time I do the ingredients separate and I end up with mushy wax that won’t really work as a solid in a stick. Can you provide more detailed instructions? How do I know when I can put the ingredients in the stick so that they won’t separate? Please help.
Ali
Tried this recipe and like others the magnesium didn’t dissolve also this doesn’t fight the smell like I hoped. I previously made the man-stink killer cream version and it worked well for about a month and then I think my body became accustomed to it and it started to be ineffective. I was hoping for a less messy recipe that would go on from a solid stick, so I thought I’d give this recipe a try.
Does anyone have suggestions for getting the magnesium to incorporate better? Also, do I just need to detox my pits? Does anyone else still smell after a hard day of work?
Annette
Hi! I made this recipe a couple of days ago, excluded the mag. flakes. I used the “oz” measure instead of Tbsp. Because my beeswax comes in a block so I couldn’t really measure it in Tbsp., anyway, I LOVE how to hardened & doesn’t smear off in globs when you glide it over your armpits. The only problem I have is that it felt “tacky/sticky” on my underarms, instead of absorbing in. could I have done something wrong? I used .5oz. Beeswax, 1 oz. Shea, .4oz. Coco butter, 1/2 Tbsp. Kaolin & 1/2 Tbsp bentonite clay.
Holly
Hi, I’ve just made this and am finding my b.o. is gone when i use it – amazing!! However i also find the texture really sticky/thick. I find it really hard to apply and am having to wipe excess off with tissues. Do you have any suggestions? I’ve followed your recipe as written though used magnesium oxide, not chloride. Appreciate any suggestions you might have! 🙂
Jeanmarie Morganelli
Excited to try the deodorant recipe! I have a tub of mango butter, can I use that in place of the cocoa butter?
Heather
I’m pretty sure it will. Shea and mango butter are pretty similar in consistency, while cocoa butter is much harder and won’t blend in this recipe without the addition of another oil. Please let me know how it works out!
Chelsea
Hi, would I be able to add arrowroot powder to this recipe without removing any of the other ingredients? If so, do you know much I would use and how I go about adding it in? Thanks!
Meredith
Hi, Heather! Thanks so much for this recipe. I’m looking forward to trying it. Is it safe to add essential oils to this recipe and then put it in a plastic container? I’ve read before that you shouldn’t mix EOs and plastic, but I’m wondering if it is fine in the this case since the product hardens. I really appreciate your help.
Shrada
Hi heather
Thanks for this post!
If I’m using pellets for the beeswax, cocoa butter etc, would I still use the measurements you’ve given or slightly less considering flakes probably weigh a lot less?
Thank you!
Meg
So the first time I made this recipe, I accidentally used Magnesium Oxide instead of Magnesium Chloride. The crazy thing is that I like it even more with the Magnesium Oxide…. it has a smoother consistency. Are you aware of any issues in using this other version of Magnesium?
Love all your posts!
Shraddha
Hi!
I’m looking forward to making this, thank you 🙂
Quick question. If using a premade solution of magnesium (I use EASE which is just the magnesium mixed in water, I saw that you recommended one teaspoon), would you need to add in an additional binder to mix the water element to the butters and oils? Also, would I then need to add a preservative since there’s a water element?
If I want to have more magnesium in my recipe since that’s the active ingredient, how would you recommend adjusting the other ingredients?
karen
When I looked up Kaolin clay online it says it is basically aluminum. Is this true? Been staying away from commercial deodorants with aluminum.
Trish
Hi, thanks for the recipe, I want to give it a go, but don’t have shea butter, cocoa or mango butters. Is it ok to omit these? Should I replace them with something else?
Thanks for your help 🙂
Ashley
I used baking soda instead of the magnesium ( providing of course I did an armpit detox a few times prior). It worked great and I also substituted coconut oil for shea because I ran out. Stick is solid and works great !
Cheryl Rivera
Hi,
I used Himalayan Salt and it worked nicely. I like that the H. Salt has the essential oils incorporated (bergamot & sweet orange) already.
Amy
Do you think I could make this deodorant with tallow instead of the cocoa butter or shea butter?
Karryn
I have used diatomaceous earth and it has gone a brown colour. Will use it tomorrow.
Jennifer
Hi! Do you think I could just add in some dried lavender to the melted oils instead of using essential oils? Could I also throw in some dried calendula? Would it then be best to strain them out of the oil, or could I leave them in the deodorant? It’s just that I have the dried herbs on hand whereas I’d have to buy EO. Thanks!
Amy
Hi, thanks for the recipe! I’m excited to transition to using natural deodorant!
I followed the recipe and found the day after that the bottom of the stick has liquid and the top is cracking it’s so dry…. what might I have done wrong? Thanks for your help!
Alma
Hello Heather! I would like to try your recipe, it sounds easy to make!
I just wanted to ask you, what do you think of the Humble brand deodorant?
I have been using it almost for a year.
Heather
I’ve never tried it but the ingredients look good.
Amber
Wow! I have made many types of homemade deodorant, but I think this may be #1 in most effective, no stinging/burning, and it lasts for 8+ hours! I didn’t have any empty deodorant containers, so I put my mixture into a glass jar and scrape it with a spatula. I also added a little bit of activated charcoal (I didn’t measure it, just did it by eye until I liked the color) and one drop of rose geranium oil. I also used the DE instead of the clay, as I didn’t have any on hand. I would recommend trying this recipe if you are on the fence 🙂
Zinia (Ζήνια)
Hi! My name is Zinia.
I’m from Greece and my English are no so fluent … any way please have patience with me.
Please explain to me
2 tablespoons grated, packed beeswax (.5 ounces by weight)
2 level tablespoons shea butter (1 ounces by weight) – where to buy shea butter
2 rounded tablespoons grated cocoa butter (.4 ounces by weight) – where to buy cocoa butter
Beacause I found that 0,5 ounces = 14,17gr. But I know that 1tbs=15gr. and you say 2tbs=30gr.
And how 2 rounded tbs are only 0,4 ounces since you say 2tbs = 0,5 ounces.
Probably something I can not understand, which all of you can. Or something is wrong.
So Please help me understand or if you can explain to me in grams.
I’ m looking forward to try your recipe.
Thank you
Ζήνια.
Mariame Sylla
What is the dilution rate of magnesium hydroxide please?
Mary Kolker
I know it’s a lot of fun to make your own natural care products, and I do make my own natural lipstick and moisturizing cream… but Deodorant is so much easier to use Vodka (yes, Vodka). Or if you find grain alcohol, 50 to 70% diluted with water. Just put in a small spray bottle and apply as needed. Works great! Eliminates odor and lasts sometimes all day, unless you’re in the heat of summer, and I live in Florida…
Can add few drops of essential oil or fragrance if desired.
I have been using it close to 10years as the only option and no, it doesn’t dry skin or have any other negative effect. I heard rubbing alcohol 70% can be used, but long term might not be desirable.
Melody Zimmerman
Charcoal deodorant is an all-natural way to stay smelling fresh and dry! The activated charcoal neutralizes odor and absorbs moisture, and creates an environment where bacteria cannot thrive, leaving your sweat odorless. Because they don’t rely on irritating baking soda as the only odor-neutralizing ingredient, these deodorants are ideal for individuals with sensitive skin or a baking soda sensitivity.
Kylie
Is there an alternative for chloride powder. form the resurch ive done it has aluminum in it witch is not goos for your skin at all and can clog your sweat glands potentially making you sweat more… help please!!
Lily
Hi Heather, I want to ask you if I could use shea and cocoa mixture? Would it make a difference, I am new to this….
Michael
Hey Heather! Question! I tried the recipe and it works great! It stayed in solid stick form even in higher tempratures. Smells strongly of honey too which I love. One thing I noticed after a few weeks is that the colour from the bees wax starts to separate from the rest of the mixture… it started as a smoothe well mixed colour and now it looks like it has separated swirls of what I imagine is watery honey or pollen? Its hard to say what exactly it is partly because I’m colourblind but it is deffinetly coming from the bees wax (which was a store bought high quality brick of wax). Any ideas? Suggestions? Have you experienced this? It doesn’t smell as wonderful a few weeks later either…
~Michael
Paula
Hi, i recently made a deodorant with Bentonite and it worked so well. But then i found out Bentonite clay has aluminum in it.
Do you have a deodorant recipe without aluminum in it?
Heather Dessinger
Hi Paula, I do have a recipe here, and I also think you might find this article regarding bentonite clay and aluminum interesting.
Katka
Hello Heather, can I substitute magnesium chloride with magnesium carbonate? Or is there something else what can I use insted of magnesium chloride?
Ann
Wow, what a waste of time and expensive ingredients!!!Followed the recipe to a T and barely got a half container filled with half liquid and half undiluted magnesium. Btw, I did ground up my flakes to a fine powder after reading the comments,before deciding to make this recipe,and used kaolin clay from frontier organics.Used some rose absolute eo and a bit of organic lavender oil.I make a lot of salves,toothpaste and other things,and this is my first fail.
Rachel Delvalle
HI Heather, I’m always a big fan of all your stuff. I was wondering if I could use magnesium oxide instead of the Mg chloride? I have a bunch left over from another project and would love to put it to good use
Heather Dessinger
I haven’t tested it but I think it’s likely. If you give it a try please let us know how it works for you!
Rachel
I did try it. I couldn’t get it all to dissolve but I worked at heating and beating for awhile and then strained it before pouring into the tube. It wasn’t perfect but the end product seemed ok so I considered it a pretty good success 🙂
Ory
HI Heather
I make this recipe with LUGOL 2% (iodine) which is very important to the body and prevent cancer.I want to ask you if the MAGNESIUM CHLORIDE suppose to contradict the iodine? because both of them are halogens and the chloride usually interupt the consuming of the iodine.
what do you think?
(sorry about my english, I am israeli…)
Rhiannon
GETTING EPSOM SALTS TO DISSOLVE COMPLETELY:
As noted in other comments, Magnesium Sulfate (Epsom Salts) is not oil or ethanol soluble.
Luckily, it IS soluble in water.
–In a small heatproof cup, mix one part Magnesium with one part water fresh off the boil and stir until dissolved.
–Add an equal part arrowroot, corn starch, or cosmetic-grade clay and stir until it is a smooth thick paste.
–If you’re having troubles getting out the lumps, transfer the mixture to a small zipper bag and massage until smooth.
Hope this helps. That’s how I did it and it came out beautifully smooth.
Trrish
Found this site a while ago….only just made this sans the magnesium. It worked well and I guess the proof will be when it is used.
Thought the recipe was really really easy – so thank you.
Ane
Hi,
Blessings from Puerto Rico. Can thr magnesium flakes be substituted by magnesium oil??
Mattie
I may have made a mistake. I followed the recipe, but the magnesium didn’t dissolve at all and the deodorant is gritty and very uncomfortable to use. Do you have any suggestions on what I may have done wrong?
Mandy
Love your emails and ideas! Thank You 🤗
Vickie McMillan
Print availability?
Shay
I love this recipe!! I have tried others and this is my favorite. I have eczema and sensitive skin. I’ve been using it for months now and it does not cause me any irritation. Happy I found a recipe without baking soda that works well
KC
This is my very favorite DIY deodorant recipe! I made 2 tubes (different scents) a year ago and I’m still using them so a little does go a long way! Talk about saving money! But the stick is pretty hard to advance. Any suggestions?
For any of you still struggling with odor using natural deodorant, try an armpit detox. The recipe is on Pinterest but it’s basically bentonite clay and apple cider vinegar and a little water to make a paste. I just eyeball it. Apply it to your armpits and wait 5-10 minutes, then wash it off. It helps. I try to do it once every 2-3 weeks but if I forget, I start to stink and it reminds me. lol. But it made it possible for me to use natural DIY deodorant.
Cyndy
Thank you so much for this wonderful resource. A question regarding the sensitive skin deodorant. Do you have a modification for no kaolin clay? I can’t wait to start trying some of these recipes. I love your M.O.M. Deo recipe, but I’m gonna try the glycerin instead of the M.O.M.
Sonie
Heather, if I have Magnesium oil rather than the flakes would the amount used stay the same?
Doreth
I love natural handmade skincare
Melissa Gordon
I love this. I never knew??
Gonna make me some deodorant. Lol
Thank you.